Skip to content

Search our store

Shop All
For Men
For Couples
Vibrators
Dildos
Anal Toys
Bondage
Lubes & Essentials
- Lubes & Liquids
- Essentials
Lingerie & Apparel
Lingerie
Babydolls & Chemises
Bodystockings
Bras
Corsets & Bustiers
Hosiery & Garters
Lingerie Sets
Men's Range
Panties & Thongs
Sleep Wear
Teddies & Bodysuits

Apparels & Costumes
Costume Accessories
Dresses & Robes
Gloves
Men's Costumes
Shorts & Skirts
Tops & Shirts
Wigs
Women's Costumes

Footwear
Boots
Heels

Search our store

Shopping Cart

Item added to your cart

Your cart is empty

Continue shopping

Subtotal

$0.00 USD

Shop All
For Men
For Couples
Vibrators
Dildos
Anal Toys
Bondage
Lubes & Essentials
- Lubes & Liquids
- Essentials
Lingerie & Apparel
Log in

Collection: Butt Plugs

Home
Butt Plugs

Sort by:

627 products

Availability

0 selected

0 selected

Availability

In stock (36 products)
Out of stock (591 products)

In stock In stock (36 products)
Out of stock Out of stock (591 products)

Price

The highest price is $180.00

From

$

-

To

$

Price:

$0 - $180

Brand

0 selected

0 selected

Brand

Adam & Eve Adam & Eve (16 products)
B Swish B Swish (3 products)
b-Vibe b-Vibe (43 products)
B.M.S. Enterprises B.M.S. Enterprises (3 products)
Bathmate Bathmate (1 product)
Biird Biird (2 products)
Blush Blush (92 products)
Blush Novelties Blush Novelties (23 products)
BMS BMS (4 products)
Crystal Delights Crystal Delights (10 products)
Curve Novelties Curve Novelties (9 products)
Cute Little Fuckers Cute Little Fuckers (1 product)
Doc Johnson Doc Johnson (34 products)
Doxy Doxy (2 products)
EDC Wholesale EDC Wholesale (1 product)
Electric Eel Electric Eel (11 products)
Evolved Evolved (10 products)
FemmeFunn FemmeFunn (3 products)
Fifty Shades of Grey Fifty Shades of Grey (2 products)
Forto Forto (17 products)
Fun Factory Fun Factory (3 products)
Gender X Gender X (11 products)
Global Novelties Global Novelties (8 products)
GVibe GVibe (2 products)
Honey Play Box Honey Play Box (1 product)
Hot Octopuss Hot Octopuss (1 product)
Hott Products Hott Products (2 products)
Icon Brands Icon Brands (10 products)
Je Joue Je Joue (4 products)
Jimmyjane Jimmyjane (1 product)
Lovehoney Lovehoney (1 product)
Lovehoney LTD Lovehoney LTD (1 product)
Lovely Planet Lovely Planet (4 products)
Lovense Lovense (6 products)
Luv Inc. Luv Inc. (8 products)
Me You Us Me You Us (6 products)
Mystim Mystim (2 products)
Nasstoys Nasstoys (27 products)
Nexus Nexus (6 products)
Njoy Njoy (3 products)
NS Novelties NS Novelties (52 products)
Nu Sensuelle Nu Sensuelle (4 products)
OhMiBod OhMiBod (3 products)
Oxballs Oxballs (14 products)
Perfect Fit Perfect Fit (2 products)
PHS International PHS International (1 product)
Pipedream Pipedream (31 products)
Playboy Playboy (6 products)
Ple'sur Ple'sur (1 product)
Pretty Plugs Pretty Plugs (1 product)
Prowler RED Prowler RED (7 products)
Rianne S Rianne S (2 products)
Rocks-Off Rocks-Off (5 products)
Romp Romp (2 products)
Rosy Gold Rosy Gold (1 product)
Rouge Garments Rouge Garments (2 products)
Satisfyer Satisfyer (7 products)
Screaming O Screaming O (1 product)
Selopa Selopa (5 products)
Shibari Shibari (1 product)
Shots Shots (21 products)
Tantus Tantus (21 products)
VeDO VeDO (10 products)
VERS VERS (2 products)
Viotec Viotec (1 product)
We-Vibe We-Vibe (1 product)
XR Brands XR Brands (26 products)
Zero Tolerance Zero Tolerance (3 products)

Color

0 selected

0 selected

Color

Amethyst Amethyst (1 product)
Aqua Aqua (1 product)
Black Black (16 products)
Black Onyx Black Onyx (1 product)
Blue Blue (4 products)
Blue Metalic Blue Metalic (2 products)
Clear Clear (6 products)
Cobalt Cobalt (1 product)
Cosmic Pink Cosmic Pink (1 product)
Crimson Crimson (1 product)
Crystal Clear Crystal Clear (1 product)
Deep Purple Deep Purple (1 product)
Diamond Diamond (2 products)
Flesh Flesh (1 product)
Gold/Red Gold/Red (1 product)
Gray Gray (2 products)
Green Green (1 product)
Gun Metal Gun Metal (9 products)
Gunmetal/Rainbow Gunmetal/Rainbow (1 product)
Inlaid Metallic Blue Inlaid Metallic Blue (1 product)
Inlaid Metallic Pink Inlaid Metallic Pink (1 product)
Just Black Just Black (1 product)
Liac Liac (3 products)
Lime Lime (1 product)
Metalic Blue Metalic Blue (6 products)
Metalic Purple Metalic Purple (10 products)
Multicolor Multicolor (1 product)
Multicolor/Rainbow Multicolor/Rainbow (2 products)
Onyx Onyx (5 products)
Pink Pink (14 products)
Pink Metalic Pink Metalic (2 products)
Purple Purple (15 products)
Purple Metalic Purple Metalic (2 products)
Rainbow Rainbow (6 products)
Red Red (3 products)
Red Crystal Red Crystal (1 product)
Rose Gold Rose Gold (5 products)
Rose Gold/Pink Rose Gold/Pink (2 products)
Rose Gold/Rainbow Rose Gold/Rainbow (1 product)
Ruby Ruby (3 products)
Sage Sage (2 products)
Satin Black Satin Black (1 product)
Silver Silver (1 product)
Silver/Diamond Silver/Diamond (1 product)
Silver/Ruby Red Silver/Ruby Red (1 product)
Teal Teal (3 products)
Vibe Green Vibe Green (1 product)
Vibe Purple Vibe Purple (1 product)
Voilet Voilet (3 products)
White White (2 products)
Yellow Crystal Yellow Crystal (1 product)

Filter and sort Filter

Filter and sort

Filter

627 products

Availability

In stock (36 products)
Out of stock (591 products)

Clear

Price

Caret Down

The highest price is $180.00

From

$

-

To

$

Price:

$0 - $180

Clear

Brand

Clear

Color

Clear

Sort by:

Remove all

627 products

Blush Novalties Avant Kaleido Silicone Plug - Lime

Blush Novalties Avant Kaleido Silicone Plug - Lime 1

Blush Novalties Avant Kaleido Silicone Plug - Lime

Regular price $14.40

Regular price Sale price $14.40

Unit price / per

Blush Novalties Anal Adventures Plug - Black

Blush Novalties Anal Adventures Plug - Black 1

Blush Novalties Anal Adventures Plug - Black

Regular price From $12.80

Regular price Sale price From $12.80

Unit price / per

Blush Novalties Anal Adventures Pleasure Plug - Black

Blush Novalties Anal Adventures Pleasure Plug - Black 1

Blush Novalties Anal Adventures Pleasure Plug - Black

Regular price $8.00

Regular price Sale price $8.00

Unit price / per

Blush Novalties Anal Adventures Platinum Silicone Vibra Slim Plug Small - Black

Blush Novalties Anal Adventures Platinum Silicone Vibra Slim Plug Small - Black

Regular price $16.80

Regular price Sale price $16.80

Unit price / per

Blush Novalties Anal Adventures Platinum Silicone Loop Plug - Small Black

Blush Novalties Anal Adventures Platinum Silicone Loop Plug - Small Black

Regular price $6.40

Regular price Sale price $6.40

Unit price / per

Sold out

Blush Novalties Anal Adventures Platinum Rabbit Tail Plug - Black

Blush Novalties Anal Adventures Platinum Rabbit Tail Plug - Black

Regular price $21.60

Regular price Sale price $21.60

Unit price / per

Blush Novalties Anal Adventures Matrix Teleportation Plug - Lunar Blue

Blush Novalties Anal Adventures Matrix Teleportation Plug - Lunar Blue 1

Blush Novalties Anal Adventures Matrix Teleportation Plug - Lunar Blue

Regular price $36.80

Regular price Sale price $36.80

Unit price / per

Blush Novalties Anal Adventures Matrix Quantum Plug - Purple

Blush Novalties Anal Adventures Matrix Quantum Plug - Purple 1

Blush Novalties Anal Adventures Matrix Quantum Plug - Purple

Regular price $16.00

Regular price Sale price $16.00

Unit price / per

Blush Novalties Anal Adventures Matrix Photon Plug - Teal

Blush Novalties Anal Adventures Matrix Photon Plug - Teal 1

Blush Novalties Anal Adventures Matrix Photon Plug - Teal

Regular price $18.40

Regular price Sale price $18.40

Unit price / per

Blush Novalties Anal Adventures Matrix Neutron Plug - Copper

Blush Novalties Anal Adventures Matrix Neutron Plug - Copper 1

Blush Novalties Anal Adventures Matrix Neutron Plug - Copper

Regular price $24.00

Regular price Sale price $24.00

Unit price / per

Blush Novalties Anal Adventures Matrix Nebula Plug - Turquoise

Blush Novalties Anal Adventures Matrix Nebula Plug - Turquoise 1

Blush Novalties Anal Adventures Matrix Nebula Plug - Turquoise

Regular price $20.80

Regular price Sale price $20.80

Unit price / per

Blush Novalties Anal Adventures Matrix Kinetik Plug - Space Age Blue

Blush Novalties Anal Adventures Matrix Kinetik Plug - Space Age Blue 1

Blush Novalties Anal Adventures Matrix Kinetik Plug - Space Age Blue

Regular price $96.00

Regular price Sale price $96.00

Unit price / per

Blush Novalties Anal Adventures Matrix Interstellar Plug - Astro Violet

Blush Novalties Anal Adventures Matrix Interstellar Plug - Astro Violet 1

Blush Novalties Anal Adventures Matrix Interstellar Plug - Astro Violet

Regular price $35.20

Regular price Sale price $35.20

Unit price / per

Blush Novalties Anal Adventures Matrix Gamma Plug - Teal

Blush Novalties Anal Adventures Matrix Gamma Plug - Teal 1

Blush Novalties Anal Adventures Matrix Gamma Plug - Teal

Regular price $19.20

Regular price Sale price $19.20

Unit price / per

Blush Novalties Anal Adventures Matrix Excelsior Plug - Astro Violet

Blush Novalties Anal Adventures Matrix Excelsior Plug - Astro Violet 1

Blush Novalties Anal Adventures Matrix Excelsior Plug - Astro Violet

Regular price $36.80

Regular price Sale price $36.80

Unit price / per

Blush Novalties Anal Adventures Matrix Bionic Plug - Cosmic Copper

Blush Novalties Anal Adventures Matrix Bionic Plug - Cosmic Copper 1

Blush Novalties Anal Adventures Matrix Bionic Plug - Cosmic Copper

Regular price $96.00

Regular price Sale price $96.00

Unit price / per

1
…
36
37
38
39
40

Subscribe to our emails

Be the first to know about new collections and exclusive offers.

Enter your email

About

Fantasy Party NYC has celebrated sexuality since 1999. Our staff has been trained to give you the best knowledgeable service that suits you the best. A young, upbeat atmosphere everyone can find something to enrich their love life

Facebook Instagram TikTok YouTube

Company

Privacy Policy
Terms of service
Refund and Return Policy
Shipping Policy

Quick Links

About us
Contact Us
Search
Your privacy choices
FAQ

Contact Info

Fantasy Party NYC
Your Online Destination for Adult Fantasy

Call us: +1 917-770-7477

© 2025, Fantasy Party NYC

Choosing a selection results in a full page refresh.